All the love,
Scarlett in the sky (with diamonds)
All the love,
Scarlett in the sky (with diamonds)
Hey There!
Paul's 'First Love', an obsession with his towns cabinet-maker was written in true Aciman fashion. It felt similar to Elio and Oliver's relationship at the beginning of 'Call Me By Your Name', the younger boy pining over the humanity of the other (see quote from page 34) . But Nanni was sweet, he was paternal and though he never indulged in baby Paul's desires it was obvious that he dared to neither squish nor shame them. This became so clear when Nanni and Paul's dad ended up being in love. It felt really full circle and comforting. This story felt the most powerful and daring to me out of Paul's loves.
Paul's 'Star Love' was interesting also. I think that he would say that his Star Love was the love of his life. Though they rarely spoke , always fought and sometimes hated each other there was a soul tie between the two which meant that they could never fall out of love with each other. This one was like an arrow to the heart, I always imagined that that is how love should look. But it was by far the least satisfying to read about. In this section he has a point of showing cheating in a really baffling way. He doesn’t make it seem unethical but rather actively experiencing something new or different, nothing more and nothing bad.
I felt it important to note a quote towards the end of the book when he fashions the lamppost simile (see bold quote below) . The lampposts standing like people in the quadrangle of his soul place presents to me almost as a Charles Dickens like version of the Christmas Carol or a TS Elliot Hollow man moment where his past selves, current self and versions of him that never materialised stood and watched him drink from the wine of life with his star love.
Once again I felt like I was reading an epic and not a romance novel. This book was so beautiful and raw. The way Aciman explores the pure fluidity of sexual desire in a shameless way paints a utopic vision for the future of love in a world that embraces the beauty of gender without using it as a prison. It shows a alternative present where experiencing feelings to their height, their capacity is the most beautiful form of self love.
MY TABS:
I am ready to have it inked on me
Forever and ever and to the next life.The gesture of a million words.
An emblem of every scream and smile.
A permanent mark of all that was, is, will or could be.
I will carry it on my sleeve
Stronger than a heart, stronger than a brain
A synthesis of the two and heightened.
It will carry me to mars in a desk chair,
And it will fly me to Italy in 1983
While I lounge in my old home, a dog purring beside me.
She will take me to the end of the world and back,
To the beginning of time and explain all that happened in-between.
It will solve all my quandaries and create more.
It will save me and destroy me all in one go.
And there it shall stay.
Perched atop my elbow, caressing my upper arm.
Until I chose to jump into it by jumping out.
It is everything and nothing,
Yet it means everything, not nothing.
It is Tolstoy, Dickens, Austen and me.
If you chose to dive in,
touch the fine lines,
The slender stroke that calculate and justify the universe in its whole.
You will die while alive and feel the most.
You will have lived a thousand lives.
All the love,
Scarlett in the sky (with diamonds)
Hey There,
I am back at it again, reviewing an incredibly heart breaking queer romance novel which shattered my soul, leaving me, like usual, in a million tiny pieces. Each of these pieces being another unrealistic expectation, little shard of grief and lethargy or just a little tear that came out of my eye. Madeline Miller’s ‘The Song of Achilles’ is historical fiction from the perspective of Patroclus, the lover of Achilles and generally just the soft most sweet boy ever.
I felt unsure going into this book and found it difficult to trudge through the first couple chapters. That is, until they kissed for the first time and I literally melted into my mattress and stayed there for about 20 minutes before resurfacing to continue on. Having studied the Trojian war at school, watched hollywood movies about it and unfortunately already knowing how the book would end I was very glad with Miller's characterisation of Achilles. He was sweet and introverted and only became vicious as a result of becoming accustomed to death. This was incredible when juxtaposed to Patroclus’ character development. It was like they were two little dots on a straight line with bad on the left and good on the right. Patroclus starts pretty far to the left and Achilles to the right and as events unfold they slowly make their way to the other side. By the end of the book we view Patroclus not as an awkward castaway boy but a powerful man who can love and fight and who wants to help people and save them, whether they deserve it or not. As Achilles becomes seasoned we see him harden and grow in fierceness but never once does his love for Patroclus quiver.
I also commend Miller on her portrayal of Bresis. Washing out the hideous narrative that likely occurred and instead presenting her as a strong female with autonomy and strength. Her last scene was especially powerful and it broke my heart. Her relationship with Patroclus was incredibly heartwarming and special. I like to think that two characters continue to live on beyond us and what we read of them. That they continue to giggle and throw olives at each other in the afterlife.
I would highly recommend this book to people who enjoy queer romance, historical fiction or just want a good old cry. I rate this book 5/5 stars because if I cry for more than 5 minutes after I’ve finished the last page, I know that I will carry it with me for the rest of my life. And oh BOY is the last page a tear jerker. I chose not to include any quotes from the end in this review because you deserve to experience them in real time.
Here are some of my highlights:
![]() |
| link |
![]() |
| link |